This is the third in a series of five blog posts on the 2017 Mapping Santa Barbara project. The first post gave an overview of the project and key findings, and the second looked at the transformational impact experienced by the Promotores. The next post describes institutional adoption of CareMaps. The final post describes how the community continues to innovate to expand on its success. You can download the full Mapping Santa Barbara final report.
There is a lot of hoopla these days about the power of combining sensors and AI to passively track and assess people’s health, and to then make expert recommendations to improve the situation. In addition to the real promise these new technologies hold, the excitement is also due to assumptions: that people are too busy or lazy to track things themselves; that people lack the expertise to make good judgments; that quantitative data is far superior to observational data; and that the more data the better.
Instead, what we discovered in the “Mapping Yourself With Guidance” portion of the Mapping Santa Barbara project is that the most meaningful and impactful learning resulted from active engagement in both data collection and analysis. A small set of data, deeply considered, was far more valuable than lots of data automatically collected and analyzed.
Six family caregivers met monthly, for four sessions from July to October, with two self-tracking experts, Rajiv Mehta, CEO of Atlas of Caregiving, and Dawn Nafus, Anthropologist and Senior Research Scientist at Intel. Participants explored new methods to track and assess their own caregiving activities and contexts. They experimented with sensor devices to track movement and sleep; paper-based tools (the Atlas CareMap, and a newly developed visual activity log) to track activities, interactions and emotions; and a concept of “track-1-thing” to understand the impact of just one type of activity.
“I became aware of stuff I never thought about — like the diversity of emotions that are experienced. It’s not like I didn’t know I had feelings, but I had never taken the time to look at them so explicitly as when doing the tracking project. It really opened my eyes to the RANGE of emotions going on inside.” Mapping Yourself project participant.
Using the visual activity log helped participants see just how busy and fragmented their days were, and how the activities of caregiving and the rest of life were so interwoven. Such tracking was difficult, requiring time and mental energy, but valuable. One participant told us, “I became aware of stuff I never thought about — like the diversity of emotions that are experienced. It’s not like I didn’t know I had feelings, but I had never taken the time to look at them so explicitly as when doing the tracking project. It really opened my eyes to the RANGE of emotions going on inside.”
Tracking steps using a Fitbit helped one participant realize that the more he walked, the more his care recipient walked. Another participant discovered that her care recipient logged more than 20,000 steps during his nightly wandering.
The response from participants about the overall Mapping Yourself effort was uniformly and strongly positive. They told us they gained new and deeper insights into their situations, seemed to enjoy trying new things, and found the discussions worthwhile. It was clear, from participants’ comments and body language, throughout the four meetings, that they were very pleased with the project and were learning a lot about themselves and their caregiving situations.
More details about the experimental methods used, outcomes, and learnings are found in the Mapping Santa Barbara final report.